Shots – Health News GOP governors stay silent amid plans to slash Medicaid spending in their states July 3, 2025 5:00 AM ET From By Phil Galewitz
—
The Challenge of Balancing Budgets
In the realm of politics and policymaking, striking a balance between fiscal responsibility and social welfare is a delicate dance. The recent discussions around slashing Medicaid spending have brought this balancing act into sharp focus.
When a Republican-controlled Congress and President Donald Trump made moves to cut Medicaid spending back in 2017, one significant hurdle stood in their way – GOP governors. These state leaders were instrumental in pushing back against the proposed cuts at that time. Fast forward to the present day, as Congress hurtles towards approving monumental cuts to Medicaid under Trump’s tax and spending legislation — totaling approximately $1 trillion over a decade — Republican governors find themselves facing a conundrum.
Medicaid, a program that serves over 70 million low-income or disabled individuals across America, has become a focal point of contention. The proposed cuts are poised to create multi-billion-dollar craters in state budgets across red states that rely heavily on federal funding for their Medicaid programs.
—
The Evolution of Medicaid Politics
The narrative surrounding Medicaid has evolved over the years, with Republicans arguing that the program swelled beyond sustainable levels during the tenures of Democratic leaders Barack Obama and Joe Biden. They contend that adding non-disabled adults to the beneficiary list expanded government assistance beyond its intended scope. Consequently, there has been a consistent push from Republicans to rein in the growth of Medicaid.
One notable feature of Trump’s tax bill is its emphasis on imposing stringent work requirements for Medicaid enrollees. This move is specifically targeted at states that expanded their Medicaid coverage under the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Interestingly, these expansion states are predominantly governed by Republicans who have been notably reticent about publicly addressing the healthcare implications of Trump’s bill.
—
Insights from Experts
According to Larry Levitt, an executive vice president at KFF specializing in health policy analysis, “It’s surprising how red-state governors have remained relatively quiet on these proposed Medicaid cuts compared to their stance during previous repeal efforts.” This observation underscores a noticeable shift in political dynamics surrounding healthcare policy within Republican ranks.
Charles “Chip” Kahn sheds light on the current landscape by highlighting how federal lawmakers are feeling pressure from legislators within their own states regarding the potential repercussions of slashing provider taxes. These levies play a crucial role in bolstering state revenue streams earmarked for healthcare expenditures.
—
A Delicate Political Dance
Political tightropes abound as Republican governors grapple with voicing concerns over Trump’s all-encompassing bill before Congress while treading cautiously not to irk the President himself. The intricate web of legislative intricacies woven into this bill extends far beyond healthcare provisions; it encompasses substantial tax cuts alongside allocations for border security and military expenditure.
Larry Jacobs points out that some GOP governors may be expressing reservations behind closed doors but opt for public silence due to fears of inviting Trump’s displeasure—a cautionary tale illustrated by Senator Thom Tillis’ recent decision not to seek reelection following clashes over policy stances with Trump.
—
As debates continue swirling around Capitol Hill concerning sweeping changes to healthcare funding mechanisms like those affecting Medicaid, Republican governors find themselves at an ideological crossroads where financial prudence intersects with social responsibility.
